If Season 1 has flaws, they are inherent to the genre: some cases resolve too neatly, and the sheer volume of high-octane emergencies (bank robberies, active shooters, cartel hits) strains credulity for a single division station. Furthermore, the show occasionally skirts the deeper, systemic critiques of policing that a more prestige-oriented drama might embrace. It is a network show, after all, and it generally presents the LAPD as a noble institution populated by flawed but well-intentioned individuals. Nevertheless, by centering a protagonist who has already failed, loved, lost, and learned, The Rookie earns its moments of earnestness.

Police procedural / Drama Starring: Nathan Fillion, Alyssa Diaz, Richard T. Jones, Titus Makin Jr., Melissa O’Neil, Eric Winter

The season is noted for its transition from lighthearted "fish out of water" comedy to a more serious drama dealing with high stakes.